|
I have become jaded over the years after watching countless anime all trying to appeal to the male population with one thing, FAN SERVICE. This spring season has taken the concept of fan service to a whole new level with Kanokon, which tends to teeter on the line between ecchi and hentai quite frequently. To Love-Ru also fits into this category and both of the mentioned anime are produced by XEBEC. Coincidence? I think not.
So you may be thinking to yourself, whats the difference between the aforementioned anime and Shoujo? Isn’t Shoujo the same, but for girls? (I mean come on there are shirtless guys all over the place). NO, thankfully Shoujo anime knows exactly where that line is and makes an effort to stay on one side (usually the more conservative side unless your reading Yaoi, then its all bets off). Another thing that Shoujo anime does that the ecchi genre (a branch of Shonen) usually doesn’t succeed at is delivering an interesting and coherent storyline. There probably are some exceptions, but I can’t think of any right now. Shoujo anime also tends to focus more on the thoughts and emotions of the main characters and altogether does character development a lot better then its male counterpart. |
|
|
Lets look at a classic anime from the summer of 2006, Ouran High School Host Club. Ouran was arguably one of the best Shoujo anime of its time and was definitely one of the best anime period. What was it that made Ouran so good? Perhaps it was the hilariously strange circumstances in which Haruhi was introduced into the Host Club, or maybe it was the colorful variety of personalities found within each of the main characters.
Ouran was a success because it managed to deliver an interesting and progressive storyline, while at the same time pulling the viewer through a roller coaster of emotions. Ouran had its funny moments as well as its more somber ones. This variety is what allowed it to go on twenty six episodes without collapsing on itself. The characters where all very different in appearance (except the twins) and personality and each one was developed fairly equally. By the end of series, we knew a lot more about each person then we did before and it helped the viewer to create a more established connection with the show. |
|
|
This spring season, I found Special A to give off a frighteningly similar feel to that Ouran. While it is somewhat a compliment for Ouran to be emulated by another anime, Special A is unable to live up to the greatness that was Ouran High School Host Club. Lets take a look at the similarities in this easy to read bulleted list:
This list could go on and on as I get more specific, but I think I’ve made my point clear. To me Special A feels like a less polished version of Ouran with the personalities of the main love interests (Haruhi / Tamaki and Kei / Hikari) swapped. Kei is the serious one in Special A while Hikari is the oblivious hardheaded do gooder that everyone takes advantage of. But I’m not saying that Special A is bad, it does have its moments and I’ve been watching it (if that means anything). However, it does suffer from something that plagues the majority of anime of this type of genre, repetition. But I suppose that if Hikari fell for Kei in one episode they would have nothing else to show for the rest of the series. This isn’t an ecchi anime after all. |
I could go on to talk about the other Shoujo anime of the season, Vampire Knight (which is basically Ouran combined with Blood+) but I won’t as I just described it in seven words, provided you watched at least a few episodes of both.
All in all Shoujo provides an escape for male viewers from the now commonplace affliction known as too much fan service or “TMFS“. Haha woot a new acronym to add to the collection. For those times that you want to watch something with a more romantic feel that has an actual storyline to it without ridiculous naked antics you can always turn to Shoujo. (Provided that they don’t reuse the same ideas over and over again). But there is always a time and place for ecchi. ;D Happy Viewing. |

S.A. is weak enough on it’s own, comparing it to Ouran just reduces it levels lower -_-”
Host club is not a shoujo anime - if anything, it is a parody on all things shoujo and yaoi!
Special A is a typical shoujo comedy with extremely shallow plot and thickheaded heroine; two or three episodes of it are OK but it gets repetitive fast.
As Kimiaru has shown, even fanservicy anime can have a decent storyline and do good in the thoughts and emotions section of character development(well, as far as 13 episodes allow).
I dropped S.A. already..
Very boring..
I regret that I even compared it to Ouran at first.
They are 2 very different animes..
Instead of doing this, give us Ouran season 2 already..^^
@issa-sa: Indeed it does.
@SinsI: Ouran is close enough that I file it under the shoujo category and Kimiaru is meh.
@Setsukyie: I wish they would give us a S2. haha.
err….so y r we talkin about boredom w/ echhi, shoujo, an yaoi??
i kno ur bored, but don’t turn on me dude…
lulz.
i hafta say though…S.A. was prty damn boring/generic, dropped after 2 episodes…